Reread: Downbelow Station, by C.J. Cherryh

Harrowing, and in many ways on par with Machiavelli’s The Prince; a fictional but realistic illustration of theoretical principles; watching what happens in a society under extreme pressure, when individuals gets reduced to the most basic animal state, fending for the self alone.

Every now and then I return to Cherryh’s Hellburner but after this most recent visit I decided I wanted to reread Downbelow Station as well.

My memory of it was that it is central to the Alliance-Union books but to its form more a foundation book, offering explanations and background rather than actual story and thus a bit dry. In this last bit I was wrong – it turned out that even if I did remember the result of the goings-on, and some of the key events and people, I had no clear memory of the tale as it evolved in front of my eyes!

The book is terrific on so many levels – the multiple viewpoints that are used to illustrate how different people end up taking different positions based on role, background, motivations and random chance; the suspense; the action; the many-layered personalities… not least of which is that of Signy Mallory, the Fleet Captain known for her ruthlessness who end up on the “good” side mainly because she dislike being ordered around. This is both a tale that illustrates what happens in war and a tale about real people caught between the proverbial rock and a hard place, with the hard place being cold vacuum.

In part I think the gap between my memory and my present experience of the book  is down to the fact that by now I have read most of the other Company Wars books so many times that characters or historical references that only gets a fleeting mention in Downbelow Station evokes a memory of some sort, and I start to wonder how Graff ended up where he did; from where Mallory came – she gets no mention at all in Hellburner, yet she says to Mazian that “we’re the oldest” – so many threads that could be picked up and expanded! Much as I enjoy the Foreigner books I do hope that Cherryh will be able to return to Alliance space, to pick a tale to tell us.

Definitely worth both a first, second and third read.

And when you have read Downbelow Station, do go on to read the others – it only adds to an already great experience!

Advertisements

11 thoughts on “Reread: Downbelow Station, by C.J. Cherryh

  1. Have you read Cyteen? I often think that Cherryh indulges a bit too much in (needless — my opinion) paranoia. Often the paranoia isn’t justified… But Downbelow and Cyteen are still deserving of their Hugos… Oh, what about Merchanter’s Luck? One of her best as well — and criminally underread.

  2. Oh yes, I have read Cyteen but not reread it during these blog years. My memory of it is that it was really good.

    Personally I don’t think the paranoia isn’t there without reason; there’s almost always someone who tries to manipulate the situation, whatever the situation is – especially if power and money is involved.

  3. Yeah, as with my blog, I’ve only reviewed what I’ve read since I started — and I don’t tend to re-read because there are so many great books out there!

  4. I rather find new friends… hahaha.

    There are a few I want to reread — Zelazny’s This Immortal, Brunner’s Stand on Zanzibar (my favorite sci-fi novel of all time), Cyteen, but — there’s so many Barry N. Malzberg novels left to read (my new obsession).

  5. I didn’t like it either — for its extremely jingoistic politics. And how the character’s don’t question the war. Hence, the power of The Forever War. Haldeman’s Forever Peace makes the point a little more forcefully, but isn’t as good as Forever War. But, I won’t be returning to Forever Peace anytime soon — I’ve only read pre-1980 works over the last four or five years.

  6. Pingback: Reread: Merchanter’s Luck, by C.J. Cherryh « re:considering

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s